 |
Arya Samaj

|
Home | Forum | Arcade
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
Shishya Administrator


Joined: 20 Feb 2006 Posts: 1985
Location: Europe
|
Posted: Tue Oct 03, 2006 7:44 pm Post subject: Christianity: Minister Claims to be Second Christ |
|
|
Creciendo en Gracia:
Minister Claims To Be Second Coming Of Christ
by
Joe Shortsleeve
CBS4 Boston.com, USA
Oct. 2, 2006
BOSTON — Is he a religious savior or a cult leader? A self-proclaimed messiah from Florida says it’s his job to save humanity. His church is called “Creciendo en Gracia” — or Growing in Grace Ministry — and there are four congregations here in Massachusetts.
The church’s leader is Jose Luis de Jesus Miranda (right) and when asked who he is, he replies “I am Jesus Christ Man. . . the second coming of Christ.”
There are now 300 congregations across the world. Annette Diaz belongs to one in Mission Hill. She says “he’s transformed my mind.” She is not alone.
Miranda’s followers in Boston truly believe they have seen the light. “We know where we came from,” said Clara Diaz. “We were angels with God that came to this earth to have a physical experience and he has taught us, he has taught us that we are perfect.”
Luis Miranda is a 60 year old former heroin addict and convict. He operates what he calls “God’s Government on Earth” from a warehouse in South Florida. Like any head of state, he is protected by a security detail that mimics the Secret Service. “I will be the President of the biggest government that this Earth has ever experienced,” Miranda said.
Miranda tells his followers they are free to indulge, to have it all. According to this modern messiah, there is no sin, no devil, and no hell to pay. Miranda says “the devil is destroyed, hell doesn’t exist, no condemnation for the chosen ones”.
Luis Miranda is certainly willing to enjoy his earthly pleasures. His followers don’t seem to mind his lavish lifestyle. I asked them, “does it make sense that Jesus Christ would drive a BMW or wear a Rolex, does that make sense to you?” Clara Diaz replied “definitely, we are in 2006.”
Cult expert Steven Hassan says this is a step by step seduction. Considered one of the nation’s top authorities on cults, the Newton based author wrote “Releasing the Bonds.” When asked what it is about this group that makes it destructive, he says, “it seems to have the top figure who claims to be God, who is perfect and is quoted as saying he has nothing to learn from anyone else. He wants to takeover the world.”
Regina Albarracin says make no mistake, this is a cult. She and her husband left the group five years ago, but their son Alvaro did not. A web entrepreneur, he has donated more than one million dollars to the church. He even left his first wife to marry another church member. He is now estranged from his family. “He destroyed my family,” Albarracin said of Miranda. “He’s the devil.”
Jennifer Casasola, a church member from Boston, disagrees. “Well if it is a dangerous cult, then it is the most wonderful cult that was ever established. Our lives have been transformed because of him and we owe him everything.”
The followers of Crescendo en Gracia have also organized marches — sometimes violent — against other religions which they say have been deceiving people for 2000 years. Although they won’t burn the Bible, they will ignite just about anything else that goes against their beliefs.
(Source) |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Shyena Gold Member


Joined: 27 Jun 2006 Posts: 964
Location: Hyderabad, AP
|
Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2006 7:26 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: | | Although they won’t burn the Bible, they will ignite just about anything else that goes against their beliefs. |
LOL!!
Okay so what has this guy done that people actually believe he's second coming of christ? What i hate is when these people claim themselves to be the awaited messiah and at the same time debunk other religions; they're better preaching in africa than gobbling up a lot of money in this fashion. _________________
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Shishya Administrator


Joined: 20 Feb 2006 Posts: 1985
Location: Europe
|
Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2006 6:34 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Namaste,
It never ceases to amaze me how short the collective memory of people is. It seems like a new 'Jesus' pops up every few years, and still each one manages to find a few thousand people who are willing to give him all of their money. Actually, it's very, very sad. _________________ Namaste,
Shishya
ॐ
ॐ सह नावतु । सह तौ भुनक्तु । सह वीर्यं करवावहै । तेजस्वि नावधीतमस्तु मा विद्विषावहै ॥
"Together may we be protected. Together may we be profited. Together may we do a hero's work. May we learn intelligently. May we never hate one another."
-Brihadaranyaka & Taittiriya Upanishads |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Shyena Gold Member


Joined: 27 Jun 2006 Posts: 964
Location: Hyderabad, AP
|
Posted: Fri Oct 06, 2006 8:32 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Namaste,
What troubles me is that these SETI's [self effable troublesome indians] never keep THIS kind of trash in newspapers... _________________
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Shyena Gold Member


Joined: 27 Jun 2006 Posts: 964
Location: Hyderabad, AP
|
Posted: Fri Oct 06, 2006 8:33 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Namaste,
What troubles me is that these SETI's [self effable troublesome indians] never keep THIS kind of trash in newspapers... _________________
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Deepan Abisuriya Junior Member


Joined: 13 Sep 2006 Posts: 66
|
Posted: Mon Oct 09, 2006 9:50 pm Post subject: Jesus warned against this long ago ! |
|
|
Namaste,
Jesus Christ says in the Bible- 'many will call themselves Christ, many will say here is Jesus, there is Jesus, but don't believe in them, they are false christs. But when I come, I will be seen by all, all around the world.' (sourse: Matthew, Luke (from the Bible)).
Even though Jesus Christ has warned against these cheaters. Yet I am totally surprised that people are becoming fools.
I should say, christianity and the christians should return to the Holy Bible to be purified, they should study and teach the Bible among themselves, when they themselves are superstitious.
They should enlighten themselves and remove superstition from their own religion rather than convert people irrationally.
What Jesus Christ said holds good to them who claim to be His followers ( but are not) - "Physician heal thyself". Chrsitians and Christianity should return to Christ to understand the purity of His message of simplicity.
I feel we hindus are better than them! Because they carry the Bible every sunday to chruch but they can't understand its holy message.
Namaste,
Deepan. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Shyena Gold Member


Joined: 27 Jun 2006 Posts: 964
Location: Hyderabad, AP
|
Posted: Tue Oct 10, 2006 3:23 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Namaste,
I doubt that - the way they interpret the bible is simply terrible; each sect interprets it as it likes. But all try to agree on one line:
"I am the only way to kingdom of heaven and there is no other way than me"
Problem with this line is that jesus also said "eat my flesh[bread] and drink my blood[wine]" but the former one is not symbolical for some reason  _________________
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Deepan Abisuriya Junior Member


Joined: 13 Sep 2006 Posts: 66
|
Posted: Tue Oct 10, 2006 8:40 pm Post subject: The way |
|
|
Namaste,
The symbolism of bread and wine is that, bread means the "scriptures "- any scripture you believe that it is holy. We are to be nourished by the words of the scripture by practice of discipline. The best is the manthra recitation of Vedas, which have the most energizing power to the reciter.
And the wine is the pure belief on God that purifies the soul and keeps away from fear. Even the scrifice of Jesus Christ.
The thought regarding the " only way" shouldnot be mistaken, as Jesus Christ is exalted and mentioned in all scriptures. In the Bible, Quran, Buddhist Scriptures, and even in the mahabhavishath purana. There is a hindu priest who became a christian after he found verses depicting Jesus Christ in the Vedas - Pastor Mani Iyer (there are so many instances like this). But why did he become a christian, Christ did't tell to become a christian. He could have been a hindu and followed Christ.
We can by being hindus believe in all scriptures. That is the greatness of hinduism, where in no one is insulted, and all faiths are regarded as sacred.
And Jesus Christ reiterated the Vedic dharma. Please read the teachings of Jesus Christ, you will find this true. Please don't go by the denominational interpretations.
And since He is believed to be the "The Word" who was in the beginning from creation with the Brahman (as per Bible and Quran, and also as per the vedantha, Baudhisathva by some Budhists), He is said to have come into the world through a virgin and to be the sacrifice for the sins of the whole world.
Not that we will not be punished for our sins, but that He took away the spiritual degradation that sin brings in our souls, that we may reunite with God. He taught karma yoga, bhakthi yoga ns gnana yoga. In this sence, He said " I am the only way...."
This is true as:
1) He is the only one who is predicted and mentioned in many scriptures universally. But our 10 avatharas are only in Bharatha khanda, thus they are not recognised universally.
2) He is considered holy and spoke the sanathana dharma (book of Daniel in the Bible).
3) Historicaly Jesus Christ is seen in many countries, before His death and after His resurection.
4) Jesus Christ is considered to be judging the world at it close as per the sathya yuga theoriest, Bible and Quran. Budhists and Zoarastrians also believe in the One who comes to judge the world, but are still not familiar with this.
Jesus Christ should not be underestimated. Jesus taught the vedic dharma very clearly. But the christian preachers project this verse as if all should become christians, because He said He is the only way (true as per above analysis).
This is the great and futile mistake they are doing, just to increase the number of their members. But Jesus Christ infact was against conversions, and He never started a new religion. He was predicted from ages in many scriptures and civilisations, He was born and led a life as it was predicted, and then fulfilled His mission on earth and will be coming to give the last judgement.
All these have historical evidences. As hindus we are to believe in " sathya meva jayathe". Conversions are high due to two reasons.
1) Hindus have not understood that Jesus Christ preached sanathana dharma and that He was also aquinted with hindus and their system. They burn the Bibles and insult Christ (not all, but some fanatics who have not read the scriptures, but claim to be religious following some leader who also has no idea of the scriptures).
They try to underestimate Him and reject Him. Which makes a person who knows the historical facts of Jesus christ and the scriptures to turn to christianity which seems to be having the truth, but the new convert after entering the religion finds out that they are just taking Jesus name, but not following Him. He also then thinks , it was better I would have been a hindu and followed Christ ( as the St Thomas christians (first christian of 2000 years history in India) did. They were hindus but believed in Christ as per the scriptures.
Vedas are not against Christ, nor Christ against the scriptures.
2) Christians hide the fact that Christ taught sanathana dharma, but portray the same sanathana dharma through the Holy Bible and confuse the new convert to think that hinduism is castelined, superstitious and have no truth.
But if christians are true followrs of the Jesus Christ, they would teach the vedas, Bible and Quran.
I am happy that hindus are doing this.
Any clarifications, please reply.
Deepan. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Shyena Gold Member


Joined: 27 Jun 2006 Posts: 964
Location: Hyderabad, AP
|
Posted: Wed Oct 11, 2006 3:39 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Namaste,
| Quote: | | The symbolism of bread and wine is that, bread means the "scriptures "- any scripture you believe that it is holy. |
What i mean to say is that they use selective interpretation over here. It wasn't bread and wine - he said flesh and blood...
| Quote: | | Even the scrifice of Jesus Christ. |
I agree he sacrificed himself, but his sacrifice was to bring back hope in those people. Not against some sin..
| Quote: | | as Jesus Christ is exalted and mentioned in all scriptures. |
Actually; I've run through all those quotes. There are supposed to be predictions of muhammad too... All of them are horrifying misinterpretations of the actual meaning...
| Quote: | | In the Bible, Quran, Buddhist Scriptures |
1)Bible and Qu'Ran don't count; for both believe in jesus - in different manners
2)Buddhist scriptures cannot be trusted - they are fabricated quite recently in my opinion. They say that world will end after 500 years of buddha's birth; ramayana happened in 100 BCE where ravana is actually a dravidian benevolent king of lanka; seeta is actually his incestuous sister and hanuman is a dravidian. I guess this makes us understand the authenticity of these scriptures...
| Quote: | | mahabhavishath purana. |
Bhavishya Purana is no longer in state of authenticity - it is a totally fabricated scripture by the britishers. Check the site encyclopediaofauthentichinduism.com for that... Too many historical inaccuracies to be considered anywhere near acceptible..
| Quote: | | There is a hindu priest who became a christian after he found verses depicting Jesus Christ in the Vedas - Pastor Mani Iyer (there are so many instances like this). But why did he become a christian, Christ did't tell to become a christian. |
No; you see this is where the christians quote the line above and people are fooled into thinking jesus wants them to convert. What the line means is that only sacrifice and love shall lead one to heaven. I believe with many others that jesus came to india during the 'lost years' and studied yoga intensively. Most of his feats can be replicated by the right vedic knowledge. Maybe; he pretended to be the prophesised messiah of the jews to lead them from the torah/talmud or whatever it is....
| Quote: | | We can by being hindus believe in all scriptures. That is the greatness of hinduism, where in no one is insulted, and all faiths are regarded as sacred. |
Not completely - we believe in NONE of the scriptures; that realisation is the only way to god; and scriptures are tools of reaching That.
| Quote: | | And Jesus Christ reiterated the Vedic dharma. Please read the teachings of Jesus Christ, you will find this true. Please don't go by the denominational interpretations. |
I doubt it. He wanted his disciples to rebel against his parents; said that those who dont follow him, are as good as being against him. In the end; one of his disciples sells him away for pieces of silver; the others flee upon seeing him cruficied - and all of these will accompany him on judgement day. The only word which defines the bible IMO is 'sin' - to the extent even the benevolent universal unitarian kaali devi bhakta as well as swami vivekananda's guru - ramakrishna paramhansa, was fed up of hearing the word sin too many times and nothing of That's benevolence.
| Quote: | | And since He is believed to be the "The Word" who was in the beginning from creation with the Brahman (as per Bible and Quran, and also as per the vedantha, Baudhisathva by some Budhists), He is said to have come into the world through a virgin and to be the sacrifice for the sins of the whole world. |
I find it silly to think a human can be a 'word'. The 'word' was more likely a reference to Its eternal word; not christ. Jewish scriptures speak of coming into the world from a young woman; not a virgin. He is also supposed to have rebuilt the third temple which was destroyed..
| Quote: | | Not that we will not be punished for our sins, but that He took away the spiritual degradation that sin brings in our souls, that we may reunite with God. |
To think that the absolute god made a mistake is fallacy for me - his word is eternal; his law is eternal; otherwise he must be imperfect...
He taught karma yoga, bhakthi yoga ns gnana yoga. In this sence, He said " I am the only way...."
This is true as:
| Quote: | | 1) He is the only one who is predicted and mentioned in many scriptures universally. But our 10 avatharas are only in Bharatha khanda, thus they are not recognised universally. |
The total number is 25; all mentioned properly.
| Quote: | | 2) He is considered holy and spoke the sanathana dharma (book of Daniel in the Bible). |
Is this one of the 'apocryphal' ones by the way...?
| Quote: | | 3) Historicaly Jesus Christ is seen in many countries, before His death and after His resurection. |
The result of being a yogi IMO
| Quote: | | 4) Jesus Christ is considered to be judging the world at it close as per the sathya yuga theoriest, Bible and Quran. Budhists and Zoarastrians also believe in the One who comes to judge the world, but are still not familiar with this. |
| Quote: | | Jesus Christ should not be underestimated. Jesus taught the vedic dharma very clearly. But the christian preachers project this verse as if all should become christians, because He said He is the only way (true as per above analysis). |
Partly agreed here.
This is the great and futile mistake they are doing, just to increase the number of their members. But Jesus Christ infact was against conversions, and He never started a new religion. He was predicted from ages in many scriptures and civilisations, He was born and led a life as it was predicted, and then fulfilled His mission on earth and will be coming to give the last judgement.
All these have historical evidences. As hindus we are to believe in " sathya meva jayathe". Conversions are high due to two reasons.
| Quote: | | 1) Hindus have not understood that Jesus Christ preached sanathana dharma and that He was also aquinted with hindus and their system. They burn the Bibles and insult Christ (not all, but some fanatics who have not read the scriptures, but claim to be religious following some leader who also has no idea of the scriptures). |
Most understand the fact actually...
| Quote: | | They try to underestimate Him and reject Him. |
I doubt it - almost every hindu i know thinks of him as a holy soul who might be an incarnation of god. Very few stick with the 'yogi' theory and even few with the 'cheat' theory.
[quote]Which makes a person who knows the historical facts of Jesus christ and the scriptures to turn to christianity which seems to be having the truth, but the new convert after entering the religion finds out that they are just taking Jesus name, but not following Him.
| Quote: | | He also then thinks , it was better I would have been a hindu and followed Christ ( as the St Thomas christians (first christian of 2000 years history in India) did. They were hindus but believed in Christ as per the scriptures. |
There is no st. thomas who visited india - even the church has dropped this story.
| Quote: | | Vedas are not against Christ, nor Christ against the scriptures. |
Depends upon how you interpret the whole of it - not a few lines..
I believe that jesus is good yes - but that he's only human; not a saviour. He was a saviour to the slaves at his time; for having given them the hope. He was a yogi who mastered it to the extent of being able to create miracles. Mind you; no gospel is in a state of authenticity - the miracles supposed to have been done by jesus in front of over 2000 people weren't recorded by ANY contemporary historian who used to keep track of even the most sensitive differnces. It is also possible that ayya vaikundar is actually his reincarnation as well. _________________
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Devo General Discussion Forum Moderator


Joined: 11 May 2006 Posts: 634
Location: Canada.
|
Posted: Wed Oct 11, 2006 3:45 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: | There is no st. thomas who visited india - even the church has dropped this story.
|
Hmmmmm, Interesting. I keep on hearing this from Christian themselves.
I'm wondering now, If there was an Apostle of Christ, named St Thomas and he did not go towards India upon Jesus' intructions, where did he travel to, according to the other denominations?... |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Shyena Gold Member


Joined: 27 Jun 2006 Posts: 964
Location: Hyderabad, AP
|
Posted: Wed Oct 11, 2006 3:50 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I cant remember the sources; but jesus had no disciple named 'thomas'. His name is judas; and is called thomas or 'twin' to distinguish him from the others.
| Quote: | | I'm wondering now, If there was an Apostle of Christ, named St Thomas and he did not go towards India upon Jesus' intructions, where did he travel to, according to the other denominations?... |
1)Did jesus instruct him?
2)If jesus indeed visited india; then he must've also learnt from india in the first place; thus he'd instruct thomas to go there - to LEARN at a maximum; not convert...
Just noticed an interesting thing....
"I stirred up Death the Apostles to slay, that by their death I might escape their blows.
But harder still am I now stricken: the Apostle I slew in India has overtaken me in Edessa; here and there he is all himself.
There went I, and there was he: here and there to my grief I find him."
First off....
1)There is no satan
2)The land wasn't called india back then.
EDIT: And something i came across wiki...
| Quote: | | To the Portuguese and Spanish conquerors and clerics, the Americas were simply "The Indies" for most of the Sixteenth century. It was inconceivable for them that so large a portion of humankind was overlooked in carrying out Christ's Great Commission : " Go ye into all the world and preach the Gospel to every creature". Soon the missionaries started discovering footprints of St. Thomas. |
Latin America to India.... _________________
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Devo General Discussion Forum Moderator


Joined: 11 May 2006 Posts: 634
Location: Canada.
|
Posted: Wed Oct 11, 2006 4:14 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Namaste,
Well, maybe 'instruct' wasn't the right word, in this discussion. However, Jesus did say to his close followers to go forth and spread the 'word'....
In the coming days or so, I will try to bring online the thoughts of Dr. Tulsi Ram, an Aryan writer, as he comments on the Satyarth Prakash, and dwell very precisely on the an Arya Samajists outlook on the general topic here, with regards to Jesus, his teachings, and the contradictions in those teachings found in the bible.
Also, I personally wouldn't trust the Church's account of the Apostle's venture, to a very high extent.
In Swamiji's commentary on Christianity, he shows how/what Jesus may have learnt about the 'word' from Vedic Literature, and currently researchers are trying to connect the pieces to show that Christ, infact travelled to India.
And, I believe he did.
If you notice in some accounts of Jesus' life, a potion of his story between the ages of approx. 10 yrs - 30 yrs is not really accounted for. Could this mean that during this period of time, Jesus travelled in search of 'truth', and found his way to the Vedas and Vedic literature, in India?
That is the question researchers are trying to figure out.... |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Deepan Abisuriya Junior Member


Joined: 13 Sep 2006 Posts: 66
|
Posted: Wed Oct 11, 2006 10:02 pm Post subject: "let all noble thoughts flow from all sides", not |
|
|
Namaste,
Thanks for all that, but I find that the above comments are more of anti-christ sentiment and not the vedic thought of " let all noble thoughts flow from all sides".
I see above the message to defame Jesus, and call him a cheat.
This is because people read the scriptures to find something to misinterpret and try to insult Christ. You have read books which contradict christianity and with a view to insult Christ, not the Bible and Quran intently.
This also happens among christians and muslims, who to portray their religion to be right would only read books which insult the vedic literature and distort them. This was one of the main reason I became a hindu, because hinduism is a religion where you find all religious thoughts in it.
I did't find aggresiveness to destroy Christ and distort His message.
The main thought is to open the mind to the facts and not collecting biased facts to insult the other religion.
Infact Jewish scripture prove that masiah will be born through a virgin, not just a woman. A jewish scholar had established it and even the dead sea scrolls have shown this as fact. What you are saying is a outdated thought of offensive judaism who try to prove that all religions are evil and only theirs is true. The above comments seems to convey the same but biased to ones personal view and not vedic or hindu thought.
I am surprised that, Bible and Quran are non-authentic.
Please read the scriptures in their true thought and you will find that they are also God's word and contain the vedic message.
Jesus life history was not written 200 years after him, infact recent archeological excavations have shown that it was written exactly at the time he walked on earth (life time of Christ -1 century). Please keep track of recent updations.
I am also astonished by the question- regarding the existance of St Thomas. The book of Acte Thomae, and many other reliable historical books of christianity in India, have him mentioned. If all are fabrications, then some even doubt the authenticity of present manuscripts of 4 vedas which are much older than these.
Speaking about puranic history, there has been so many instances where the archeologies and historians disproved some events and later said that it was the fact.
Ramayana is also authentic and historical.
Regarding flesh and blood interpretation, you are to read the whole new testiment. I will give you quotes from where the christians interpret these verses, but later.
Let me tell you, please don't read the history as you want it to be. Don't read the Bible and Quran as to find something to insult. All religions are well established with historic authenticity for thousands of years, with spiritual meanings and interpretations. Respect them and try to find the truth, and not only to contradict them. Reading Davince code and satanic verses will make the thought anti-christian and anti-islamic.
Look to all the facts and not biased to support yours or someones who never had studied these scriptures, but had read it, or discussed it. Studying and reading, makes difference espeacially when we read the holy scriptures.
This will only destroy knowledge. But the open minded aproach to all scripture is the true vedic view.
Jesus Christ was not a cheat, but Holy Word. There is nothing to mock on this thought, as it has more of a spiritual understanding and scriptural quotes than just say that I can't believe. The critics of the Holy vedas also claim to have found nothing valuable in them . They are blind leading the blind. But enlightened mind comprehends those things which critics mind can't. Let us not be so. You may mis-quote and misinterpret the sayings of Jesus, but can't prove them.
Swamy Dayanad Saraswathi brought a thought provoking approach to all religions in his "light of truth', but not a ani-christ or anti-islamic, anti-jewish, anti-jain or anyother "anti-" sentiments.
Any comments, please be free, I learn a lot from you.
Deepan. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Shishya Administrator


Joined: 20 Feb 2006 Posts: 1985
Location: Europe
|
Posted: Thu Oct 12, 2006 1:37 am Post subject: |
|
|
Namaste Deepan,
I respect your desire to instill peace between the religions. To strive for peace is a noble goal, and such a thing takes courage, especially in times such as these. Indeed, what we need is understanding in regards to the various cults of the world, and not blind rejection. Therefore, I very much appreciate your intent.
At the same time, however, I feel I must make one thing clear: We do not know the original teachings of Jesus. For that matter, we cannot even prove that such a man really existed. All we have to go on is the available literature and the doctrines of those who call themselves Christians. Therefore, it makes little sense for us to make conjectures about what he 'really taught, said or did'.
I, for one, have no interest in apologizing for the Christians. Do their doctrines, as they teach them, make sense? In my eyes, they do not. Is it my job to interpret and/or correct them so that they do? Not at all. That is the job of Christians and Christians alone. I can tolerate Christians for their faith and devotion. But I can't be expected to make sense out of that faith. Nor can I be expected to share in that devotion. My tolerance is all that can be expected.
I don't know anything about Jesus for certain, and I don't think anyone will be able to provide me with solid proof of anything in this regard. Therefore, I will not insult Jesus. But neither will I claim that he was a holy man. I will leave that to those who claim to know.
For the sake of the discussion, however, let us suppose - as Deepan and Devo indicated - that Jesus travelled to India during those 'lost years' and that, upon his return, he was teaching Vedic Wisdom to his people. The fact would remain that the authoritative scriptures of the Christians fail to make this evident. It may be that those texts have been manipulated and distorted so as to conceal this. Or it may be that his followers never really understood his teachings in the first place. Regardless, there remains a discrepancy between the recorded teachings of Jesus and those of the Vedas which cannot be overlooked without sacrificing a great portion of the content of the latter.
Therefore, such discussion may prove useful in helping a Christian return to Vaidik Dharm, but otherwise serves only to blur the lines between the Truth of Vaidik Dharm and the sectarian doctrines of the various cults in the world. _________________ Namaste,
Shishya
ॐ
ॐ सह नावतु । सह तौ भुनक्तु । सह वीर्यं करवावहै । तेजस्वि नावधीतमस्तु मा विद्विषावहै ॥
"Together may we be protected. Together may we be profited. Together may we do a hero's work. May we learn intelligently. May we never hate one another."
-Brihadaranyaka & Taittiriya Upanishads |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Shyena Gold Member


Joined: 27 Jun 2006 Posts: 964
Location: Hyderabad, AP
|
Posted: Thu Oct 12, 2006 5:23 pm Post subject: Re: "let all noble thoughts flow from all sides", |
|
|
[quote="Deepan Abisuriya"]Namaste,
| Quote: | | Thanks for all that, but I find that the above comments are more of anti-christ sentiment and not the vedic thought of " let all noble thoughts flow from all sides". |
The reason i take this view is because all people are pro-christ; until one looks at all points of view he cannot judge the true nature of any character. I greatly respect muhammad - how many have not called him a paedophile? Why should i not frame them as anti-islamic? The reason is one word - awareness.
| Quote: | | I see above the message to defame Jesus, and call him a cheat. |
I've seen similiar reactions where they call me a racist for showing the authenticity and science of the varna system of hinduism. All i did there; was show you the other view - jesus has nothing to do with hinduism, period. he came to india and became the master yogi who saved the west by bringing them hope.
| Quote: | | This is because people read the scriptures to find something to misinterpret and try to insult Christ. You have read books which contradict christianity and with a view to insult Christ, not the Bible and Quran intently. |
I've read no books at all dear. Instead i argue that he is a mahaatma who was a master yogi; and fiercely against those who consider him a myth.
[quote]This also happens among christians and muslims, who to portray their religion to be right would only read books which insult the vedic literature and distort them. This was one of the main reason I became a hindu, because hinduism is a religion where you find all religious thoughts in it.
| Quote: | I did't find aggresiveness to destroy Christ and distort His message.
The main thought is to open the mind to the facts and not collecting biased facts to insult the other religion. |
I agree; its just that I dont think that god will sacrifice himself in front of the cross - this is only to show humanity that god loves them though they might think otherwise. He wont sacrifice himself; nor his son to change some law - it was always the same -- good people go to heaven, bad to hell. I also argue that if jesus crucified himself to wash our sins away - then we should follow his true word that kingdom of god is within us; and there's no need to "have faith that jesus is our saviour" or stuff - for he already washed our sins away.
| Quote: | | Infact Jewish scripture prove that masiah will be born through a virgin, not just a woman. |
Trust me upon this -
| Quote: | | A jewish scholar had established it and even the dead sea scrolls have shown this as fact. |
| Quote: | | What you are saying is a outdated thought of offensive judaism who try to prove that all religions are evil and only theirs is true. |
Now THIS is anti-jewish - for jews say that all will be judged upon their morality; and even have belief in rebirth [called gilgul-neshamoth]. Lez not forget - jews aren't responsible for his crucifixion - its the result of a mistranslation; just as 'young woman' was mistranslated as 'virgin'!
| Quote: | I am surprised that, Bible and Quran are non-authentic.
Please read the scriptures in their true thought and you will find that they are also God's word and contain the vedic message. |
Which is why I say they're no longer in state of authenticity - we have to derive the true principles from them.
| Quote: | | Jesus life history was not written 200 years after him, infact recent archeological excavations have shown that it was written exactly at the time he walked on earth (life time of Christ -1 century). Please keep track of recent updations. |
These proofs are yet to be verified. As i said - all i do; is show all POV's. I believe jesus is a mahaatma; but not son of god or something...
| Quote: | | I am also astonished by the question- regarding the existance of St Thomas. The book of Acte Thomae, and many other reliable historical books of christianity in India, have him mentioned. If all are fabrications, then some even doubt the authenticity of present manuscripts of 4 vedas which are much older than these. |
How could he have visited latin america; which is also called 'indies' and india? Word from a book cannot be trusted - a book is only material; can be tampered and the like. Indeed; one can doubt the authenticity of vedas - so he should put them to test. This is how i accepted vedas to be authentic and made a tremendous shift from agnostic views to staunch theism. None of my friends think i'm a staunch theist though - they instead think i'm a rationalist atheist...
| Quote: | | Speaking about puranic history, there has been so many instances where the archeologies and historians disproved some events and later said that it was the fact. |
And the likewise too.
| Quote: | | Ramayana is also authentic and historical. |
Of course..
| Quote: | | Regarding flesh and blood interpretation, you are to read the whole new testiment. I will give you quotes from where the christians interpret these verses, but later. |
You didn't get my point, did you? What i mean is that jesus meant 'I am in everything' by his line of blood and flesh. This is interpreted as symbolical; however when he said "I am the only way to god" this is translated as line promoting prosletysation. IMO; jesus declares here that only through sacrifice and love for all humanity; can one attain That.
| Quote: | | Let me tell you, please don't read the history as you want it to be. Don't read the Bible and Quran as to find something to insult. |
On the other hand i tell my friends how consistent qu'ran is with vedas. I dont know much about bible on the other hand...
| Quote: | | All religions are well established with historic authenticity for thousands of years, with spiritual meanings and interpretations. Respect them and try to find the truth, and not only to contradict them. Reading Davince code and satanic verses will make the thought anti-christian and anti-islamic. |
I read none of them actually. About da vinci code; I'd actually respect jesus much more if he really married mary magdalene - for he's expounding the concept of grhastha which many people of modern days think will not take you to That.
| Quote: | | Look to all the facts and not biased to support yours or someones who never had studied these scriptures, but had read it, or discussed it. Studying and reading, makes difference espeacially when we read the holy scriptures |
Actually I'm opposed to calling anything - even vedas; as holy. They were all messages of That for their aforesaid time; and vedas bear knowledge that was meant for satya yuga when all was perfect. In the end of kali yuga; all religions will again merge into one and the true meaning of vedas will be revealed. IMO; all we can trust now is bhakti and realisation; and follow a good code of conduct. No matter what one says; the one of vedas is difficult for modern times.
| Quote: | | This will only destroy knowledge. But the open minded aproach to all scripture is the true vedic view. |
Trust me; I'm a totally different person in and out of debates. My opinion is that vedas are the only complete message of That; the others are messages that will slowly converge the views of mankind to the true religion.
| Quote: | | Jesus Christ was not a cheat, but Holy Word. |
Jesus Christ was not the Holy Word; but godsent messiah who opened the eyes of the west and rejuvenated the stagnating minds of the east.
| Quote: | | There is nothing to mock on this thought, as it has more of a spiritual understanding and scriptural quotes than just say that I can't believe. The critics of the Holy vedas also claim to have found nothing valuable in them . They are blind leading the blind. But enlightened mind comprehends those things which critics mind can't. Let us not be so. You may mis-quote and misinterpret the sayings of Jesus, but can't prove them. |
I welcome you to check my orkut account's posts - not even in one; do i use posts from other scriptures. Instead i show his inconsistency of views of hinduism through quotes of our scriptures..
| Quote: | | Swamy Dayanad Saraswathi brought a thought provoking approach to all religions in his "light of truth', but not a ani-christ or anti-islamic, anti-jewish, anti-jain or anyother "anti-" sentiments. |
I simply feel; swamiji was trying to convince the dogmatics that vedas are truly beautiful thus he had to abuse the other religions - after all, he gave the word to his guru.. _________________
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Deepan Abisuriya Junior Member


Joined: 13 Sep 2006 Posts: 66
|
Posted: Thu Oct 12, 2006 8:36 pm Post subject: Super.... |
|
|
Namasteji,
The thoughts above show that we are speaking the same thought in different angles.
I studied the Bible and Quran and then the vedas. What I found is that the Quran says that the Bible has to be read, and the Bible predicts that the Quran will be given. And our Vedic scriptures say us to open our minds to all noble thoughts.
Basiscally as per history, the Vedas were given first, then the Bible and then we see the Quran. This means that we find God's message to all people in differrent times. As I read the scriptures in this view, I found no contradiction what so ever. Even regarding Jesus Christ's divinity, or Muhamad's prophetic words. I also believe in the 24 saints of the Jainism.
In all I find no missing links and that all have their own place in the scriptures and religious world.
I intensely share the Vedic thought to christians through the Bible, to muslims though the Quran and to other religious people with their own holy books. I only found that every religion wants to criticise one another and nothing but increase their population strength. But the scripture don't teach this.
As I studied the Holy Bible, I believe in its authenticity and its historicity. There are a lot of historical facts regarding Christ and His divinity. Untill I get a solid evidence to ripe Christ of His divinity, I can't do it. So it is with the Muhammad as a prophet, the 24 tirthankars as the Jainas, and Budha as the "enlightened one".
I am really surprised that you have read the Quran, but not the Bible, Bible was written before Quran and Quran tells us to read the Bible.
I think as you start doing research on the Bible you may understand the Quran better as I comprehended the Bible message in the Quran. Ultimately as you said all will converge to the vedic thought. Absolutely agreed.
But what is the vedic thought? Is it not Bible and Quran message of peace and love? If divinity of Christ in the Bible is not agreeable to you, then the predictions of the Daniel (not a apocriphal book) and Revelation in the Bible, which have come true historically become absurd. Their predictions have come true and no one can deny this. In fact it clearly mentions the massiah's time of death on the cross, which was exactly the time of Christ's death. And the events predicted in the Jewish scriptures which massiah will do has come true in Jesus. Please read the old testament Bible, which is the Torah of the Jews.
I am not anti-jewish. I respect them as I respect my race (hindu). The Bible and Quran gives high regard to them as they are the children of Abraham and that God revealed to them in history as He does to us (hindus) through the power of Vedic recitation. They didnot kill Jesus Christ, infact the first converts to christianity were all jews who found Christ fullfilling the predictions of the massiah in the old testament. I would not go to the detail as you have not read the Holy Bible.
Any way, it was a excellent discussion with you.
Thanks for this.
Deepan |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Devo General Discussion Forum Moderator


Joined: 11 May 2006 Posts: 634
Location: Canada.
|
Posted: Thu Oct 12, 2006 8:45 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Namaste,
Well, I can see a discussion triangle here, basically. However, in a nut shell, it boils down to 'truth', and the evolution of truth through the pages of all these scriptures.
At the end of the day, it's about our vision of truth, our understanding of truth, and how we would present this truth to others. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Deepan Abisuriya Junior Member


Joined: 13 Sep 2006 Posts: 66
|
Posted: Thu Oct 12, 2006 9:05 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Namasteji,
Thats the enlightening thought of putting the spiritual knowledge to practical living, that all may live with the living individual.
Thanks.
Deepan. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Shishya Administrator


Joined: 20 Feb 2006 Posts: 1985
Location: Europe
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Devo General Discussion Forum Moderator


Joined: 11 May 2006 Posts: 634
Location: Canada.
|
Posted: Fri Oct 13, 2006 3:39 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Deepan wrote: | | Thats the enlightening thought of putting the spiritual knowledge to practical living, that all may live with the living individual. |
I agree, bro. It makes us stronger individuals when we live and let live. This does not mean we have to take any injustice from anyone, we can be our own individuality, but at the same time maintain a positive attitude and respect towards others.
| Shishya wrote: | | I think something like "The Teachings of Jesus Christ in Light of Vedic Wisdom" would be a very interesting topic, not only for us here, but also for Christians. Would something like that interest you? There is no pressure , but we would all be very thankful, I believe. |
I second that, every word of it...  |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Prabhat Platinum Member


Joined: 18 Jul 2006 Posts: 1155
Location: Holland, The Hague
|
Posted: Fri Oct 13, 2006 12:34 pm Post subject: |
|
|
are baap re, pagal lokh to bahut hai dunyia me. _________________ Namaste,
Prabhat |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Shyena Gold Member


Joined: 27 Jun 2006 Posts: 964
Location: Hyderabad, AP
|
Posted: Fri Oct 13, 2006 3:02 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: | | I am really surprised that you have read the Quran, but not the Bible, Bible was written before Quran and Quran tells us to read the Bible. |
The reason being that I dont feel I can trust the prevailing translations; nor do I know which version I can trust. Qu'Ran; there's only one version. I didn't read the whole of qu'ran either; but a significant number of quotes from it. Two of most favourite being:
"Let there be no compulsion of religion - truth will clearly stand out from error"
"Knowledge is light; Ignorance is | | |